
Update 11-29-03
I hope everyone had a wonderful and rewarding
Thanksgiving this past week. Aside from attacking the turkey leftover
issue with some new and occasionally successful recipe innovations, I
have had a moment or two to ponder what I am thankful for. The family
issues are personal but the job and Union related realities are potent.
If you have any interest at all I'll mention some of them in the last
paragraph.
There's not a lot of hard data to report this week as both houses having
wrapped it up and recessed. But as long as I'm in the introspective
mood I'll try and address the dominant question I have been asked this
last week which goes something like the old Chicago song, "Where do we
go from here?" Alas my crystal ball is on the fritz as it has been all
my life but my best guesses would be summed up by ripping off the Boy
Scouts motto "Be Prepared".
The immediate temperature of our dilemma has been lowered a few
degrees. While we all, myself included, could use a little breather
after the intensity of the last half year or so, the threat of
privatization and wholesale manipulation of air traffic is still very
real. A letter from the FAA Administrator promising a one year
moratorium on the issue doesn't stop them from researching and
strategizing. We can also expect to see Congressional hearings on the
matter that I would presume would be more of an orchestrated show of
support for a conclusion than an actual open airing of issues and fair
assessment of the question. Nevertheless, NATCA will continue to strive
to keep the facts at the forefront and hopefully get the chance for real
testimony.
For reasons of slavish ideology and/or greed, air traffic is at the
forefront of the White House's management agenda. Many members have
said it makes no sense and they just cannot conceive of how they could
really be serious about this knowing the facts of our performance (it
ain't broke don't fix it) especially in a post 9-11 world. The problem
here, I believe, is rooted in our current climate of polarization. From
talk radio to the political book wars it seems we are collectively
encouraged (or in some cases ordered) to be on one side or the other of
political ideology. Pundits seem to assume that your total agreement is
an absolute price of admission to the club, and tend to spend most of
their time not in real discussion of the facts or merits of an issue,
but in the vitriol of name calling to explain how anyone who thinks
differently is an idiot or worse. If I can take the arrogant position
that I am 100% right then therefore you must be 100% wrong. Open minded
analysis is then seen at best as a weakness in your lack of commitment
to the cause or at worst treasonous. This climate of extremes is alive
and well on both sides of the political equation and unfortunately for
us, we were unlucky enough to be the poster child victim of the most
current rabid ideology. And that ideology goes something like this ...
all privatization is good ... period. Expanding it a little further,
services provided by government inherently bad ... same services
provided by private sector ... good ... period. And then the worst
motivator, services now provided by government that some private entity
could be making money on .. Very Bad! The fact that the actual product
we provide is the safest and most cost-effective and efficient in the
world is unfortunately irrelevant. Is there room for improvement? You
betcha there is Skippy. Russ Chew's plans with the new ATO have been
embraced by NATCA and this is the appropriate way to reform the largess
of the FAA and getting it on track in supporting the operation
effectively.
So back to the crappy Chicago song. Where we go depends mostly on the
election results next November. If there is a change in the White House
or change in the control of the Senate/House our dilemma will be greatly
eased if not eliminated for awhile. But if that doesn't happen and
assuming there is no shakeup in the Administration (I don't see Andrew
Card or Carl Rove going anywhere) I believe the heat will be back full
force. From the removal of our inherently governmental status thru the
present, our opponents have been continually caught off guard by our
ability to uncover their moves, draw attention to them and garner public
and congressional support (most shockingly for them with Republicans).
But nothing makes me believe that ideologically they can let it lie for
that might appear as backing down.
Now for the record, I am thankful to be represented by this Union. I
see the current situations with some other Unions or employee
representation groups and while things aren't always ideal, I am darn
sure glad we have folks on the job with the recourses and savvy to
fight the fight. I am thankful we have wisely chosen to break out of
the stereotypical Union political stance and actively reach across the
aisle for Republican support. I am thankful to have a small role in the
fight for what is right and necessary for the public, our jobs, and the
future integrity of the system. And I am thankful that we have quality
people like all of you on the job both keeping my family and me safe
when we travel and also answering the call to activism in these
challenging times. Happy Holidays. Be prepared. |